good evening everyone. so … i just watched atonement. wonderful movie, but it’s made me a bit of an emotional wreck. i tried to read the book over the summer, but i wasn’t able to get into it. i generally don’t watch movies without reading the book, but it was on sale for purchase at blockbuster, so my mom decided to get it, and i’ve been dying to see it.
i have a habit, which i suppose could be either good or bad, of putting myself into a movie when i watch it (usually when the movie involves some sort of romance). that of course can be quite delicious when the plot goes well, but in the case of atonement, it pretty much tears you apart.
now, if you haven’t seen or read atonement and don’t want to have it spoiled for you, i wouldn’t read on from here because i am going to refer to specific aspects of the film/book. here, i’ll even give you some space.
.
..
…
….
…..
….
…
..
.
okay, here goes. so in the film (i will refer to the film since i haven’t read the book, and don’t know how much of the book is preserved in the film), there’s this tension between cecilia (keira knightly) and robbie (james mcevoy), which is obviously sexual tension, and is early on revealed as such. okay, so that’s great, right? love burning in both their hearts, that they just need to reveal? well, the circumstances that push them to reveal their feelings to one another also ultimately ruin their lives. cecilia’s 13-year-old sister, bryony (played by multiple actresses throughout the movie) catches a glimpse of an uncomfortable exchange between bryony and robbie. robbie accidentally breaks a vase, and part of the shattered vase falls into the fountain. incensed, cecilia takes off her dress and goes into the fountain in her undergarments, and when she comes out, she is … well, she might as well be naked, because the material is so thin. robbie of course looks right at her when she emerges from the water, but then turns, as a gentleman should. bryony only sees cecilia removing her clothing, and then her coming out of the water, soaked in her underthings. this immediately plants the seed of suspicion in her mind, which is inflamed by the fact that she has a bit of a crush on robbie herself.
later, robbie composes a letter to cecilia to apologize for his indecency earlier that afternoon, and has difficulty finding the words. at one point, he writes a letter detailing the sexual things he dreams of doing to her. finally, he writes a proper letter, and heads over to give it to her (her brother invited him over for dinner that night, so he was going there anyway). on the way, he runs into bryony, and asks her to deliver the letter for him. all of a sudden, he realizes that he accidentally enclosed the dirty letter inside the envelope, and not the proper one. bryony reads the letter, and deduces that he must be some sort of sex fanatic, and then delivers it to bryony, but not in the envelope. cecilia realizes the horror of what just happened, and immediately speaks with robbie when he arrives. this leads to her confession of her love for him, and they make love in the library (against the bookcase), and then bryony walks in on them. this all finally comes to a climax when later that night, bryony stumbles upon her cousin being raped by her brother’s friend. he runs off, and bryony says she saw him, and says it was robbie. she then tells the police that it was robbie, and he is arrested and sent to jail. he is ultimately given the choice of staying in jail, or joining the army. he chooses the latter.
cecilia leaves her family and becomes a nurse, and meets up with robbie whenever he has leave. the next big chunk of the movie is basically the horrors of war. to make this brief, by the end of the movie you find out that cecilia and bryony never reconciled, because cecilia was killed in a bombing that broke the gas and water lines (she drowned in a subway tunnel), and robbie died the night before he was going to get shipped back to england. its so freaking tragic.
so this is where it becomes problematic for me. if you don’t know already, i have a boyfriend. we’ve been together for a year, and i love him dearly. i also miss him terribly, because we are in a long distance relationship, and i haven’t seen him for a few months. so, to be confronted with a movie like this, in which by putting myself in cecilia’s place i essentially place a death sentence on my relationship with matt, is quite traumatic. i’ll be fine by tomorrow, but right now i’m just a little haunted. i mean, imagine that your boyfriend was wrongly accused of something so nasty as pedophelia, and then only being able to see him a few times a year, living in a ghastly environment, and ultimately being spearated from him permanently, and all of that could have been prevented if your little sister didn’t tell one lie. it makes you a train wreck!!! just seeing two passionate lovers separated is awful enough, but adding everything else on top of that is downright torturous.
*sigh* why do i do this to myself? anytime i ever even remotely consider losing matt in some fashion, i break down in tears. this movie just about sucked me dry. if i had been able to cuddle him while watching it, at least i could have been consoled knowing that he was right there by my side, and that he wasn’t going to suffer and die.
i do admit, it was a very well done movie. probably just not the best set of viewing circumstances for me. i am tempted to try and read the book again, now that i know that there is something interesting to look forward to after the first 30 pages or so. we’ll see how that goes.
it’s never enjoyable to mentally live out your worst nightmare.